Top 10 Personal Crumbl Cookies Ranking & Reviews

Having gotten this as a mystery cookie was such an absolute treat and surprise! This cookie is one of my favorites for a reason: it’s exactly like one of my beloved candies, Almond Joy. At the same time, unfortunately, I could see some dislike for it because of that.

Reviewed for week of March 1, 2023.

I love oatmeal, bananas, peanut butter, and of course, cookies. Put it all together, and you get this: a terrific cookie that feels like they added some flour to some peanut butter banana oatmeal and baked it.

Reviewed for week of February 6, 2023.

I did NOT expect this cookie to be this good; in fact, I expected to almost certainly dislike it. When I think of Neapolitan, I think of ice cream. It is a fairly bland three-flavored ice cream that makes me wonder why I didn’t buy the chocolate fudge overload instead. Tangent aside, this cookie, along with the frosting, brings out the best of all three worlds: chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry.

Reviewed for week of February 20, 2023.

There was hype online about this cookie, with many speculating how they adjusted the recipe, making it a shell of its former glory. I’ve never had this previous speculated about cookies, unfortunately, so I cannot compare. What I ended up receiving, though, was amazing. Was there actually a better version of this previously? Maybe. Nonetheless, even as someone who isn’t a huge fan of Golden Oreos or Vanilla in general, everything about this cookie came together perfectly!

Reviewed for week of December 22, 2022.

I’ll just get this cookie because it’s the mystery one and I’ve never had it before, nuts aren’t even my thing really. Oh, wait a second, this tastes absolutely amazing. The nutty flavor, the sweetness, everything from the composition and texture to the taste, was wonderful and turned a nut hater like me around!

Reviewed for week of December 19, 2022.

Who doesn’t love churros? They’re a soft-crunchy cinnamon-sugar stick of magic. In cookie form, though, the magic follows. This cookie was a delight from start to finish. It hits on everything that makes a churro so darn good, throws it into a cookie form, and adds a wonderfully tasty frosting on it.

Reviewed for week of January 30, 2023.

I genuinely want these at my wedding–forget the cake! Crumbl’s Wedding Cake cookies would suit such a momentous occasion as they sport such a premium quality berry-tasting cookie but also don’t go overboard so as to not offend any of your potential wedding guests.

Reviewed for week of June 26, 2023.

Crumbl already makes a super yummy chocolate chip cookie, and what they did for this cookie is what I believe is their “Chocolate Chip 2.0.” They took everything that made their original great and added a few specific ingredients and a light amount of toppings to bring it to the next level.

Reviewed for week of December 4, 2023.

I get it. Not everyone likes mint, but this is on my personal list! They’ve had other mint-based cookies that were around as good as this, though. Who wants to see multiple mint cookies on the same list? Anyhow, Aggie Blue Mint is right up your alley if you enjoy mint. The cookie base, which consists of cookies and cream bits, is a nicely added touch and makes the combination with mint quite interestingly tasty!

Reviewed for week of October 3, 2022.

I tend to really dislike Crumbl’s darker cookies because they’re more on the bitter side and less on the sweet. This tricked my taste buds when I bit into it, though. There was no bitterness! It was sweet! And creamy! It was really, really good! I have never had a chocolate cookies and cream cookie before and gosh, I’ve been missing out.

Reviewed for week of January 30, 2023.