Crumbl Cookie Review: Galaxy Brownie, Tres Leches, Vanilla Crumb Cake, and Ultimate Peanut Butter

by Victor Martelle
Updated:

Descriptions

💫 GALAXY BROWNIE
A brownie cookie covered in a warm fudge glaze and sprinkled with rainbow candy bits.

🥛 TRES LECHES (NEW)
A buttery, cakey cookie served with a side of tres leches sauce then topped with decorative whipped cream, fresh strawberry, and a pinch of cinnamon sugar.

🍰 VANILLA CRUMB CAKE FT. GOLDEN OREO®
A cookie with Golden OREO® crumbs topped with a swirl of vanilla cream cheese frosting and more delicious Golden OREO® crumbs.

🥜 ULTIMATE PEANUT BUTTER
A peanut butter lover’s delight—an explosion of peanut butter from the cookie, to the stuffing, to the drizzle.

Summary

Two great cookies, two not so much. There’s a reason why Vanilla Crumb is dubbed the GOAT. If you do go this week, get the Vanilla Crumb and Tres Leches.


Full Review

A childhood snack of mine, Galaxy Brownie, alongside one of my favorite desserts that is tres leches, this week was a must for me. The Galaxy Brownie however, was severely disappointing, tasting like a raw, dry, dark cocoa powder. The Tres Leches was likely as close as you could get to the real thing except in cookie form. Ultimate Peanut Butter was a bland disaster. Lastly, what took the cookie cake for me was the famous Vanilla Crumb Cake ft. Golden Oreo. It was… perfect, nothing more, nothing less.

💫 GALAXY BROWNIE
Score: 4 / 10
Like a dark chocolate cake but with a dry dark cocoa powder taste. Didn’t taste or have the texture of a Galaxy Brownie whatsoever. The frosting was thin and completely overwhelmed by the cookie base. Even milk didn’t save this! Disappointing.

🥛 TRES LECHES (NEW)
Score: 7 / 10
Not moist like tres leches, it instead was a soft baked, light cinnamon cookie with sweetened condensed milk and cinnamon whipped cream on top. Despite this, it was an enjoyable, good copycat of tres leches in cookie form.

🍰 VANILLA CRUMB CAKE FT. GOLDEN OREO®
Score: 10 / 10
In spite of the apparent recipe change according to some reviewers, it had a perfectly sweet, Golden Oreo vanilla taste. The tangy’ish flavor it also had in the background was unexpected and made it absolutely perfect!

🥜 ULTIMATE PEANUT BUTTER
Score: 3 / 10
No different than scooping plain peanut butter out of a jar and eating it. The flavor is literally just plain peanut butter, and the texture is pretty standard for a Crumbl Cookie. This needed seasonings like salt and sugar to be good.



Leave a Comment