Crumbl Cookie Review: Vanilla Glaze ft. Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Birthday Cake, Neapolitan, and Hazelnut Churro ft. Nutella

by Victor Martelle
Updated:

Descriptions

✨ VANILLA GLAZE FT. CINNAMON TOAST CRUNCH™
A cinnamon sugar cookie topped with a vanilla cream cheese glaze, crushed Cinnamon Toast Crunch™ pieces, and a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar.

🥜 CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CHIP
A lip-smacking chocolate cookie packed with melty REESE’S peanut butter chips.

🎂 BIRTHDAY CAKE
A fluffy cake batter cookie with vanilla cream cheese frosting and a splash of rainbow sprinkles.

🍓 NEAPOLITAN (NEW)
Rich chocolate and smooth vanilla cookies beautifully stacked and topped with tart strawberry frosting.

❓ HAZLENUT CHURRO FT. NUTELLA (MYSTERY FLAVOR)
This Crumbl classic is a cinnamon cookie stuffed with hazelnut spread and encased with a cinnamon-sugar coating.

Summary

Looked like a decent lineup but it still fell short. The Neapolitan was one of their best cookies ever. Skip everything but the Neapolitan if you do go.


Full Review

Whenever I see Cinnamon Toast Crunch anything, I’m hyped, it’s my favorite cereal. Unfortunately, the cookie was severely lackluster. However, an amazing surprise was Neapolitan. It was simply perfect. The Hazelnut Churro ft. Nutella was the biggest letdown as both Churro and Nutella are also one of my favorite flavors. I didn’t bother getting the Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip as they’ve had a lot of peanut butter based cookies lately and I was just tired of them!

✨ VANILLA GLAZE FT. CINNAMON TOAST CRUNCH™
Score: 5 / 10
Super soft and fairly plain. Needed a lot more cinnamon and sugar to even be worth considering. Nothing like the cereal either, more like a regular, almost plain cinnamon cookie. Glaze isn’t really noticable. I have an updated review of this cookie here.

🥜 CHOCOLATE PEANUT BUTTER CHIP
Score: N / A
Didn’t get.

🎂 BIRTHDAY CAKE
Score: 6 / 10
Fairly sweet, vanilla-like sugar cookie, just not crunchy like one. Instead, it’s more chewy and soft like a premium underbaked sugar cookie. Frosting has a very sweet, birthday-vanilla cake flavor.

🍓 NEAPOLITAN (NEW)
Score: 10 / 10
Super thick and chewy. All three flavors were perfect and nothing overshadowed the other, you could literally taste each one individually. Right amount of sweetness where it isn’t too much or too little either. Just, amazing, likely the best cookie from Crumbl I’ve had.

❓ HAZLENUT CHURRO FT. NUTELLA (MYSTERY FLAVOR)
Score: 6 / 10
Just an OK cinnamon cookie with good, soft-chewy, thick texture. Like the Vanilla Glaze cookie, this could also have been more cinnamony and sweet. Also, barely any Nutella in it! Why is the Nutella layer so thin?!


Four Crumbl Cookies up close lined up in a pink and white box. Vanilla Glaze ft. Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Birthday Cake, Neapolitan, and Hazelnut Churro ft. Nutella.

Leave a Comment