Crumbl Cookie Review: Caramel Apple, Pumpkin Roll, Aggie Blue Mint, M&M

by Victor Martelle
Updated:

Descriptions

🍏 CARAMEL APPLE
A warm cinnamon apple cookie topped with caramel cream cheese frosting, chopped Granny Smith apples, a drizzle of real caramel, and a housemade streusel.

🎃 PUMPKIN ROLL
A pumpkin cookie with a perfect blend of autumn spices topped with a spiral of smooth vanilla cream cheese frosting.

💙 AGGIE BLUE MINT™ (NEW)
A universally-loved cookies and cream cookie covered with delectably minty blue buttercream.

🥜 ORIGINAL FEATURING PEANUT BUTTER M&M’S® CANDIES
Our classic cookie studded with Peanut Butter M&M’S® Candies and stuffed with creamy peanut butter.

Summary

Great selection and flavors, my personal favorites were the Aggie Blue Mint and Pumpkin Roll. Not a week to skip.


Full Review

All these cookie flavors and textures mimic the “real” foods they copy so well! My two personal favorites were the Pumpkin Roll and Aggie Blue Mint, both were so amazing! However, if you’re not a fan of mint, you may not like the Aggie Blue Mint cookies too much. The white chocolate chunks in the Aggie Blue Mint and the amazing combination of toppings of the Caramel Apple were surprisingly delicious!

🍏 CARAMEL APPLE
Score: 8 / 10
The Caramel Apple cookie tasted as advertised. It was fairly sweet and had a nice apple flavor throughout. The frosting combined with the caramel and streusel on top was a wicked combination both for flavor and varying textures. This is especially good if you love those dipped apples or fruits.

🎃 PUMPKIN ROLL
Score: 8 / 10
Pumpkin rolls with cream cheese frostings don’t miss, and neither did this cookie. It tasted almost identical to a typical pumpkin roll except the texture was just slightly different, although still quite soft and lightly chewy.

💙 AGGIE BLUE MINT™ (NEW)
Score: 9 / 10
A personal favorite, if you aren’t a fan of mint at all, you may not like this! The cookies and cream cookie base topped with a non-overwhelming minty buttercream was perfect. I especially liked how prominent the white chocolate was in the cookie itself, it was quite chunky and sweet! What an interesting cookie where all the flavors combined nicely!

🥜 ORIGINAL FEATURING PEANUT BUTTER M&M’S® CANDIES
Score: 6 / 10
This was pretty decent although it was a bit more tame on the sweetness compared to the others. Was there supposed to be a layer of peanut butter inside? I couldn’t tell, although this cookie was already quite peanuty!


Crumbl M&M and Aggie Blue Mint up close.
M&M and Aggie Blue Mint up close.

Leave a Comment