Crumbl Cookie Review: Snickerdoodle, Eggnog, Frozen Hot Chocolate, Birthday Cake, Red Velvet, and Macadamia Nut

by Victor Martelle
Updated:

Descriptions

✨ SNICKERDOODLE
Soft, yet crispy—a sweet vanilla sugar cookie coated in a sparkly cinnamon sugar crust.

🥛 EGGNOG (NEW)
A festive sugar cookie topped with smooth eggnog buttercream frosting and a sprinkle of ground nutmeg.

🍫 FROZEN HOT CHOCOLATE
A rich chocolate cookie smothered in hot cocoa-flavored mousse and topped with fluffy mini marshmallows.

🎂 BIRTHDAY CAKE (HOLIDAY)
A deliciously smooth cake batter cookie topped with vanilla cream cheese frosting and a dash of red-and-green sprinkles.

⚪ RED VELVET WHITE CHIP
Your favorite cake, elevated—a dark red velvet cookie loaded with gooey white chips.

❓ MACADAMIA NUT (MYSTERY FLAVOR)
The classic cookie filled with layers of creamy white drops and buttery macadamia nuts.

Summary

Not too bad of a week. The new Eggnog flavor was surprisingly pretty decent although Red Velvet wasn’t great. Give this week a try if you’re able.


Full Review

All of these flavors are something I adore and are personal favorites of mine. Even hyping this week up, the cookies came out to be pretty decent overall. I was especially excited for my all time favorite flavor, red velvet, although that fell flat. The chilled Frozen Hot Chocolate and Eggnog cookies were surprisingly good though. What took the cookie cake however. was the mystery flavor for that week, Macadamia Nut. Frankly, it was one of the best cookies I’ve had from Crumbl!

✨ SNICKERDOODLE
Score: N/A
Didn’t get.

🥛 EGGNOG (NEW)
Score: 7 / 10
Like eggnog in terms of flavor, although slightly less sweet. The cookie has a soft and chewyish texture. Serving it chilled was a nice addition.

🍫 FROZEN HOT CHOCOLATE
Score: 9 / 10
Tasted as advertised, like you’re eating a frozen hot chocolate in cookie shape. The frosting was noticeably on point, nothing too sweet or overwhelming. Served nice and chilled.

🎂 BIRTHDAY CAKE (HOLIDAY)
Score: 5 / 10
This is pure sugar and hardly has any real flavor. It’s like as if you were making a vanilla cake but quadruped the sugar (and I LOVE sweets!). Absolutely needs more of a birthday flavor and to tone down the sweet levels.

⚪ RED VELVET WHITE CHIP
Score: 6 / 10
Exactly like a standard chocolate brownie, not so much red velvet. Would have liked more red velvet flavor and a cream cheese frosting to bring this up a few notches.

❓ MACADAMIA NUT (MYSTERY FLAVOR)
Score: 10 / 10
The best out of all of them, combining a nicely sweet, nutty, chewy cookie. Taste alongside the soft texture made this as perfect as it gets.



Leave a Comment