Crumbl Cookie Review: Cookies & Cream, Mallow Creme, Sugar (Gold Coin), Mint Brownie, Butterscotch Chip, Almond Coconut Fudge

by Victor Martelle
Updated:

Descriptions

🥛 COOKIES & CREAM
A marbling of chocolate and vanilla cookies all topped with a white chocolate drizzle and crumbly cookie pieces.

☘️ MALLOW CREME FT. LUCKY CHARMS®
Inspired by the iconic cereal—rich with white drops, vanilla marshmallow frosting, and Lucky Charms® marshmallows sprinkled on top.

💰 SUGAR (GOLD COIN)
Some sweet vanilla smoothness with a chocolate gold coin on top. Don’t spend it all in one place.

🍫 MINT BROWNIE
For those who love brownies with a minty zing topped with a chocolate ganache.

🧡 BUTTERSCOTCH CHIP (NEW)
A sweet and smooth duo of butterscotch chips and flaky salt.

❓ Almond Coconut Fudge (MYSTERY FLAVOR)
A rich chocolatey cookie topped with a spread of sweet coconut, melty milk chocolate, and crunchy almonds.

Summary

A pretty good week overall. The Pi Day specials were great! A week to not skip.


Full Review

I saw the number of specials this week and figured it was worth a Crumbl visit. I wasn’t exactly excited about any of these but in the end, I left more than satisfied. Notably, the frosting from the Mallow Creme was the softest frosting I’ve ever had. The Sugar (Gold Coin) was interesting―I wish it had more of those cute chocolate coins on it! Lastly, my all time favorite Crumbl Cookie I had up until now was presented: the Almond Coconut Fudge. Reason being is that Almond Joy is one of my favorite candy bars, and this cookie absolutely nailed it!

🥛 COOKIES & CREAM
Score: 5 / 10
Like a big regular cookies n’ cream cookie, nothing special apart from that. It’s got a fairly dry texture and overall, kind of plain. Expected more chocolate and cream chunks as well as sweetness to bring it up a notch.

☘️ MALLOW CREME FT. LUCKY CHARMS®
Score: 9 / 10
Softest frosting I’ve ever had, like a sweet cloud of marshmallow! Cookie itself is thick, sweet, and has super thick white chocolate chunks. Definitely reminds me of Lucky Charms although it’s almost certainly sweeter.

💰 SUGAR (GOLD COIN)
Score: 7 / 10
A fairly sweet and semi-soft vanilla cookie. It reminds me of one of those Lofthouse cookies which are basically sweet sugar cookies. Wish it had more of those cute gold coins!

🍫 MINT BROWNIE
Score: 9 / 10
Not as strong as a Peppermint Patty or other minty candies but the mint is there and balances nicely with chocolate. Cookie itself is a regular chocolate cookie and semi-soft.

🧡 BUTTERSCOTCH CHIP (NEW)
Score: 6 / 10
Kind of plain, not much butterscotch flavor. Slightly sweet and semi-crunchy.

❓ Almond Coconut Fudge (MYSTERY FLAVOR)
Score: 10 / 10
Happy Pi Day! This tasted exactly like an Almond Joy! It nailed it with a semi-soft cookie base and the right amount of toppings and sweetness.


Six Crumbl Cookies up close in a pink and white box. Cookies & Cream, Mallow Creme, Sugar (Gold Coin), Mint Brownie, Butterscotch Chip, Almond Coconut Fudge.

Leave a Comment