Crumbl Cookie Review: Sugar ft. Mother’s Circus Animal, Chocolate Cake, Kentucky Butter Cake, and Peanut Butter Banana

by Victor Martelle
Updated:

Descriptions

🎪 SUGAR FT. MOTHER’S® CIRCUS ANIMAL®
A rainbow sprinkles cookie smothered with a puddle of melty white chips then topped with a Mother’s® Original Circus Animal® Cookie and a splash of rainbow sprinkles.

🍫 CHOCOLATE CAKE
A rich chocolate cookie topped with smooth chocolate fudge frosting and shaved chocolate curls.

🧈 KENTUCKY BUTTER CAKE
A yellow butter cake cookie smothered with a melt-in-your-mouth buttery glaze.

🍌 PEANUT BUTTER BANANA (NEW)
A chunky oatmeal cookie smothered with banana frosting, a tasty peanut butter drizzle, and a crunchy dried banana chip.

Summary

Two good cookies, the other two, not so much. If you only get one cookie, get the Peanut Butter Banana, otherwise, skip this week.


Full Review

There was a lot of hype going around about the Kentucky Butter Cake. The other cookies, well, I wasn’t too interested in them. However, the opposite happened. I found the Kentucky Butter Cake to be pretty boring and found the Peanut Butter Banana and Chocolate Cake to be great. I really want to highlight the Peanut Butter Banana, it was one of the best Crumbl cookies I’ve ever had! The Sugar ft. Mother’s Circus Animal was indeed a circus, quite funny for how bad it kinda was.

🎪 SUGAR FT. MOTHER’S® CIRCUS ANIMAL®
Score: 4 / 10
Bland and a little crunchy. Even the frosting was thin and flavorless. Basically, it’s a boring, below average sugar cookie. You’re better off getting their Pink Sugar.

🍫 CHOCOLATE CAKE
Score: 7 / 10
Absurdly chocolatey… I needed milk. I wish it had more complexity to it. Even as a chocolate glutton, it was just simply too much.

🧈 KENTUCKY BUTTER CAKE
Score: 5 / 10
Slight buttery taste with a slight crunch, not much else. Overall kinda boring and bland. I expected a lot more from all the hype around this.

🍌 PEANUT BUTTER BANANA (NEW)
Score: 10 / 10
Exactly like banana oatmeal (cookie base was oatmeal) with a hint of peanut butter. Nothing artificial tasting or overly sweet, just perfect! It really feels as though they made peanut butter banana oatmeal and threw it into the oven. One of my favorites!


Four Crumbl Cookies up close lined up in a pink and white box. Sugar ft. Mother's Circus Animal, Chocolate Cake, Kentucky Butter Cake, and Peanut Butter Banana.

Leave a Comment