Crumbl Cookie Review: Mallow Sandwich ft. Oreo, Confetti Milkshake, Skillet Cookie, Milk Chocolate Chip

by Victor Martelle

Descriptions

💫 GALAXY BROWNIE
A brownie cookie covered in a warm fudge glaze and sprinkled with rainbow candy bits.

🖤 MALLOW SANDWICH FT. OREO®
A fluffy, creamy center with brownie pieces sandwiched between two chocolate cookies made with OREO® cookie pieces.

🫐 BLUEBERRY MUFFIN
A warm blueberry cookie covered with a buttery glaze and topped with a delightful blueberry muffin streusel.

🍨 SKILLET COOKIE (NEW)
A warm and gooey semi-sweet chocolate chip cookie topped with a scoop of vanilla bean mousse and a drizzle of semi-sweet chocolate.

🎉 CONFETTI MILKSHAKE
A confetti sugar cookie rolled in rainbow sprinkles and topped with cake-flavored buttercream and a dollop of whipped cream.

🍪 MILK CHOCOLATE CHIP
The classic—you can’t go wrong. Thick, soft, and packed with milk chocolate chips.

Summary

While I liked the Confetti Milkshake the most, all of the cookies this week are a must try!


Review

Perhaps one of Crumbl’s most favorite cookie (according to fans), the Mallow Sandwich, and a new one called the Skillet Cookie?! Sign me up!… Wait! So, after trying them, they were just… decent. I was kind of disappointed in both, honestly. However, the underdog, the Confetti Milkshake, saved the day! Yet, even through my disappointment, I still recommend people try these cookies if they’re able. They’re all unique and I’m sure at least one or two of them will be a hit with you!

💫 GALAXY BROWNIE
Score: N / A
Didn’t get this week although I did get it before.

🍨 SKILLET COOKIE
Score: 6 / 10
It’s like they compressed their Chocolate Chip cookie into a thinner form factor. It’s a little more crunchy overall but it definitely resembles the semi-sweet, traditional skillet cookie. Unfortunately, the soft topping was bland and reminded me of a soft, unflavored buttercream. Honestly, the regular Chocolate Chip cookie Crumbl has is better!

🍪 CHOCOLATE CHIP
Score: 7 / 10
A very good chocolate chip cookie. It’s soft on the inside, slightly crunchy on the outside. It’s decently sweet and the chocolate chunks are wonderful, so much better than chocolate chips… yes, I know, they use chocolate chips but they’re GIANT and CHUNKY!

🎉 CONFETTI MILKSHAKE
Score: 8 / 10
This is a sweet vanilla cupcake in cookie form. The cookie is thick, sweet, and has a nice vanilla flavor. The confetti is an appreciable composition addition as well. Lastly, the thick frosting on top tastes exactly like a sweet vanilla, perfect for this cookie and is identical to the frosting found on vanilla cupcakes! Not to mention, the dallop of whipped cream on top of the frosting makes it even more interesting!

🫐 BLUEBERRY
Score: N / A
Didn’t get this week although I did get it before.

🖤 MALLOW SANDWICH FT. OREO
Score: 7.5 / 10
This is easily two cookies in one, what a value! In terms of everything else though, the dark chocolate cookies are on the crunchier side but still soft enough, and they are semi-sweet overall. Likewise, the thick whipped cream in the middle is also semi-sweet. Reminds me of a crunchier whoopie pie and in my opinion, while it’s a good cookie, nowhere near their top ten and shouldn’t be as popular as it is.



Leave a Comment