Crumbl Cookie Review: Blueberry Crumb Cake, Dark Dream, Cookie Dough, and Ultimate Peanut Butter

by Victor Martelle
Updated:

Descriptions

🍇 BLUEBERRY CRUMB CAKE
A lemony graham cookie with pops of blueberries and a zesty lemon glaze.

🍫 DARK DREAM
A decadent chocolate cookie packed and topped with loads of melty, gooey semi-sweet chocolate chips.

🧑‍🍳 COOKIE DOUGH
No spoon required—a brown sugar cookie topped with cookie dough buttercream and chunks of delicious cookie dough pieces.

🥜 ULTIMATE PEANUT BUTTER
A peanut butter lover’s delight—an explosion of peanut butter from the cookie, to the stuffing, to the drizzle.

Summary

Just an OK week, no standouts. You can skip this week.


Full Review

I wasn’t exactly super excited for this week although most of the cookies looked OK and interestingly, the looks matched the tasted. Frankly, there were no standouts here. I feel each cookie could have been slightly nudged in different directions to improve them.

🍇 BLUEBERRY CRUMB CAKE
Score: 6 / 10
Mildly sweet, filled with blueberries and had a slight overall lemon taste. Texture was interesting, slightly crunchy on the outside and crumby in the middle. Wish it was a tad sweeter.

🍫 DARK DREAM
Score: 6 / 10
It’s a fairly chocolate-chocolate cookie. Expected it to be a bit sweeter or have a frosting to sweeten it up. It’s honestly kind of boring and a pretty typical chocolate based cookie.

🧑‍🍳 COOKIE DOUGH
Score: 7 / 10
This thick cookie tastes like a chocolate chip cookie without the chips. Frosting is thick and almost cookie-dough-like, also giving it that cookie dough flavor.

🥜 ULTIMATE PEANUT BUTTER
Score: 3 / 10
No different than scooping plain peanut butter out of a jar and eating it. The flavor is literally just plain peanut butter, and the texture is pretty standard for a Crumbl Cookie. This needed seasonings like salt and sugar to be good. (Note: Not shown in pic. View my previous review here.)


Four Crumbl Cookies up close lined up in a pink and white box. Blueberry Crumb Cake, Dark Dream, Cookie Dough, and Ultimate Peanut Butter.

Leave a Comment