Post Naughty List Cocoa Pebbles with Marshmallows Cereal Review & Release Date


Review

Let’s not kid ourselves, these are rebranded Cocoa Pebbles with Marshmallows! Of course, this doesn’t mean they’re bad in any sense; in fact, they’re one of my personal favorites — throwing marshmallows into Pebbles?! Can you even make it better? The sweet, mildly dark chocolate taste, combined with the marshmallows, makes it a touch sweeter and creamier than your regular Pebbles, and adds contrast to the crunchy rice mouthfeel.

Like regular Cocoa Pebbles with Marshmallows, these are great both dry and in milk, but especially in milk! I love how it all clumps together and gets a bit soggy — the mouthfeel and richness that comes from the milk adds so much! Not to mention, this version makes your milk appear milky-black! After some time, they lose the black coating and reveal the Cocoa Pebbles layer underneath.

My only nitpick is Post making this cereal coal-black. It could trick people into thinking this is an ultra-dark Wednesday-copying cereal, so don’t be fooled!

You can find my cereal tier list here.

Release Date

Released late September/early October 2026. Found in early October 2026 at Walmart.

Victor's Biscuits Logo.

Rating: 9.5 / 10


Leave a Comment