Millville Peanut Butter Bats Review & Release Date


Review

Wow, I love the smell of these. It’s a very peanut-buttery smell and reminds me a lot of Reese’s Puffs, minus the chocolate aroma — although they do look like Reese’s Puffs, with orange and darker pieces shaped like bats. These have an interesting texture as well. They feel like they have a smooth, waxy coating, which makes them soft and “moist,” if that makes sense. Texture-wise, the cereal is reasonably crunchy. 

First, this cereal is amazingly dry. It literally tastes like you’re eating through a jar of Skippy or Jif peanut butter, with a pinch of dark chocolate. There’s no sense or taste of any corn or traditional cereal flavors; this is nearly entirely peanut butter. It feels like Reese’s Puffs’ cousin, except Puffs yields a heavier chocolate flavor, though both cereals have about the same level of sweetness. This cereal is really amazing, especially if you enjoy peanut butter. 

In milk, a small amount of the peanut butter flavor is lost to the milk itself, which is a good trade-off, in my opinion, because you get a mildly peanut butter-flavored milk. On the other hand, the cereal remains mostly crunchy and doesn’t really soften much. 

Overall, I like these much better dry because, as someone who enjoys softer cereal in milk, these didn’t soften much, if at all, which is a big letdown for soggier-cereal enjoyers like me. Still, the primary peanut butter forward here is so good, you don’t even need milk, but I would definitely rank this higher if it got softer in it.

You can find my cereal tier list here.

Release Date

Millville released Peanut Butter Bats and S’mores cereals around September 2025. Found in early November 2026 at Aldi.

Victor's Biscuits Logo.

Rating: 8 / 10


Leave a Comment