

Review
First, these aren’t bad; they just aren’t my thing!
I love the packaging of these. The black box, the orange-and-gold coloring, and the overall design are really cool. Unfortunately, the individually wrapped Pop-Tarts packages in this box are your standard grey and boring Pop-Tarts bags.
These Pop-Tarts have a sprinkle of orange-colored crunchy bits and a layer of white frosting on top of the regular-looking Pop-Tarts pastry. Inside, the filling matches the color of the pastry itself, essentially blending in. It’s a soft, solidified filling, like many other Pop-Tarts, though not as gooey as some others.
Biting in, I’m actually surprised. It’s not as bold or as intense as the marketing on the box, nor as punchy as many of the other Pop-Tarts fruit-based flavors. Instead, it comes across as very inoffensive and almost welcoming. You have the traditional lightly buttery Pop-Tarts pastry flavor, and a more distinct, genuine orange taste. No soda or carbonated flavor here. This orange is not at all punchy; it comes across as mild to moderately sweet–not as sweet or sharp as, say, an orange juice drink or an actual orange–perhaps the pastry tones all of that down.
Unfortunately, when heated, the flavor doesn’t change at all. The pastry simply gets softer.
Overall, these are orange-flavored Pop-Tarts with amazing marketing, nothing more, nothing less.
You can find my Pop-Tarts tier list here.
Release Date
Released late October/early November 2026. Found at Walmart in late October 2026.

Rating: 6.5 / 10
