Crumbl Cookie Review: Lemon Poppy Seed, Texas Sheet Cake, Raspberry Cheesecake, Monster, and Sea Salt Toffee

by Victor Martelle
Updated:

Descriptions

πŸ‹ LEMON POPPY SEED
A zesty lemon cookie packed with yummy poppy seeds, then stuffed with a lemony filling and smothered in a lemon almond glaze.

🍫 TEXAS SHEET CAKE (NEW)
A warm, cakey chocolate cookie with a fudgy glaze and crunchy toasted pecans.

🍰 RASPBERRY CHEESECAKE
A deliciously decadent jamboree including a buttery graham cracker cookie, smooth vanilla cheesecake frosting, and a dollop of fresh raspberry jam.

πŸ‘» MONSTER
All the flavors you could ask forβ€”peanut butter, chocolate candies, semi-sweet chocolate chunks, brown sugar, and oatmeal, all rolled into one.

πŸ§‚ SEA SALT TOFFEE
A delicious infusion of toffee and milk chocolate chips, topped with a dash of sea salt.

Summary

Mediocre week overall. If there’s one decent cookie, it’s the Raspberry Cheesecake. You can skip this week.


Full Review

Going into this week, I wasn’t necessarily hyped for any of these and thought “meh, just OK.” Coincidentally, the cookies were just that, I even gave most cookies 6 / 10 across the board. They weren’t bad, they were just… OK. The Raspberry Cheesecake was the only decent one, although even that wasn’t a standout.

πŸ‹ LEMON POPPY SEED
Score: 6 / 10
Slightly dry and a more plain than I thought. Wish it had more sweetness like their other lemon based cookies, although the poppy seed wasn’t a bad combination with the lemon. Also needed a lot more filling in the middle for it to really be noticable.

🍫 TEXAS SHEET CAKE (NEW)
Score: 6 / 10
Big, airy, kind of a dry chocolatey cookie. Wish it had more frosting or something to give it more “oomph.” Average amount sweetness, just about right.

🍰 RASPBERRY CHEESECAKE
Score: 7 / 10
A cold, chunky, soft and chewy cookie. Kind of sweet, has a nice raspberry and cheesecake tasting frosting where most of the flavor originates from.

πŸ‘» MONSTER
Score: 6 / 10
Slightly dry and crunchy. Not too sweet, and has a little bit of every flavor and texture present including the peanut, marshmallow, and chocolate. I’m actually surprised each flavor was represented so equally!

πŸ§‚ SEA SALT TOFFEE
Score: 6 / 10
Texture and sweetness level is a lot like their regular chocolate chip cookies but the taste is slightly salty and has a light toffee taste.



Leave a Comment