Crumbl Cookie Review: Dulce de Leche, Cake Batter, Buckeye Brownie, Maple Oatmeal

by Victor Martelle
Updated:

Descriptions

🥛 DULCE DE LECHE
A beautifully spiced cinnamon cookie smothered in layers of creamy dulce de leche caramel and frosting.

🥜 BUCKEYE BROWNIE
A decadent treat with layers of chocolate brownie, buckeye peanut butter, and a smothering of melted semi-sweet chocolate.

🍁 MAPLE OATMEAL (NEW)
Like a warm bowl of oatmeal—a soft cinnamon maple cookie topped with a maple glaze and a generous sprinkle of oat streusel.

🍰 CAKE BATTER
A trifecta of cake batter goodness, including a swirl of cake batter cream cheese frosting and mini cake batter balls.

Summary

Overall, a very good week with a lot of variety. Each cookie offered a wonderful, different experience.


Review

When I saw this week, I was hyped, and despite being hyped, I was not at all let down! Each cookie was equally good in its own right. My favorite was the Cake Batter because frankly, I love the taste of overly sweet cake frosting. The most interesting was the Maple Oatmeal because it tasted like I was eating a literal oatmeal bar.

🥛 DULCE DE LECHE
Score: 8 / 10
Chewy, thick, cinnamon, lightly sweet cookie with a nice layer of dulce de leche and cream on top. If dulce de leche had a cookie form, this would be it.

🍰 CAKE BATTER
Score: 9 / 10
A sweet vanilla cookie that breaks apart easy and topped with the sweetest frosting ever! This frosting was light in texture and tasted similar to the sweet vanilla canned frosting you’d buy in a store. Overall, it did taste a lot like a vanilla cake with a lot of frosting.

🥜 BUCKEYE BROWNIE
Score: 6 / 10
A dark chocolate cookie that breaks apart easy and topped with non-sweet peanut butter and chocolate. If you’re not into sweet cookies, this is for you, otherwise, I wish it was sweeter!

🍁 MAPLE OATMEAL (NEW)
Score: 7 / 10
If you made oatmeal and let it sit and harden up a bit, this would be it. The cookie base was super oaty and chewy in both taste and texture. The overall cookie was a light cinnamon and sugar, nothing overly sweet, just a tasty oatmeal cookie.


Four Crumbl Cookies up close lined up in a pink and white box. Dulce de Leche, Cake Batter, Buckeye Brownie, Maple Oatmeal.
Four Crumbl Cookies up close lined up in a pink and white box. Dulce de Leche, Cake Batter, Buckeye Brownie, Maple Oatmeal.

Leave a Comment