Crumbl Cookie Review: Confetti Cake, Peanut Butter Cup ft. Reese’s, Lemon Cheesecake, and Rocky Road

by Victor Martelle
Updated:

Descriptions

πŸŽ‰ CONFETTI CAKE
A burst of confetti sprinkles in a fluffy sugar cookie topped with a swirl of pink vanilla cream cheese.

πŸ₯œ PEANUT BUTTER CUP FT. REESE’S
A classic peanut butter cookie swirled with melty peanut butter and sprinkled with chopped REESE’S Peanut Butter Cups.

πŸ‹ LEMON CHEESECAKE (NEW)
A buttery graham cracker cookie topped with a creamy lemon cheesecake frosting and a tart punch of lemon curd.

🍫 ROCKY ROAD
A chocolate cookie stuffed with marshmallow filling then covered in semi-sweet chocolate chips and almonds.

Summary

Good cookies this week, although Rocky Road was disappointing. A week not to skip.


Full Review

I was hyped for Rocky Road but I ended up almost falling in love with several of the other cookies. The surprising standout for me was the Reese’s Peanut Butter cookie because I had their ultimate peanut butter recently and hated how bland it was. Also notably, their confetti cake tasted like an upgraded version of the Pink Sugar.

πŸŽ‰ CONFETTI CAKE
Score: 7 / 10
A bit like their Pink Sugar but not nearly as sweet despite the thick frosting. Great chewy texture, like a really good confetti-vanilla-like cookie!

πŸ₯œ PEANUT BUTTER CUP FT. REESE’S
Score: 8 / 10
Unlike their Ultimate Peanut Butter version, this is balanced by the sweet taste of Reese’s baked in. Tastes like a mix of regular peanut butter plus Reese’s, making it not super sweet as well as being chewy, and frankly, just perfect!

πŸ‹ LEMON CHEESECAKE (NEW)
Score: 7 / 10
Cheesecake? More like a super sweet, chewy, lemon tart cookie! Tasty nonetheless! The cookie base is buttery and the frosting provides it the strong tarty lemon flavor.

🍫 ROCKY ROAD
Score: 4 / 10
One of my favorite flavors but Crumbl failed this. Too dark, almost like eating raw dark cocoa powder, overwhelming everything. The texture was also on the crunchier side which didn’t help. Did they mess this up?


Four Crumbl Cookies up close lined up in a pink and white box. Ultimate Peanut Butter, Confetti Cake, Lemon Cheesecake, and Rocky Road.

Leave a Comment