Other
Jimmy’s Cookies Hot Fudge Sundae Bakery Cookie
Score: 5 / 10
Review
Crumbly and on the drier side, it does feel cheap. Despite being dry, it’s soft enough to be called, well, soft. It’s not chewy by any means, though. Also, the confetti and embedded bits contribute nothing.
The taste is nothing more than an artificial, semi-sweet dark chocolate. It’s not bitter by any means; it’s just dark. Really, that’s it for the flavor; it’s kind of boring and in no way resembles what it advertises.
Release Date
Released in early July 2025 as part of Walmart’s Freshness Guaranteed bakery lineup. The launch features four soda flavored treats: Dr Pepper, Hawaiian Punch, Orange Crush, and 7 Up. These are available as mini cake bites, bundt cakes, and cupcakes. It also includes PB&J inspired items such as PB&J bars, grape jelly cupcakes, and PB&J bites. Finally, the lineup offers s’mores flavored goodies including mini donuts, muffins, frosted cookies, and cupcakes. See sources here and here). Found July 2025.
Jimmy’s Cookies Peanut Butter Candy Made With Reese’s Pieces Bakery Cookie
Score: 5.5 / 10
Review
A mostly plain buttery cookie with a hint of peanut throughout. It’s nothing as strong as a Reese’s or even regular peanut butter, let alone other peanut cookies. Unfortunately, the taste is pretty plain; it tastes like they had an average cookie and added just a lick of peanut.
The texture is pleasant enough. It’s soft and lightly moist; you’re able to pull it apart, which is nice. Notably, compared to its Hot Fudge Sundae cousin, this texture is a lot better.
Release Date
Released in early July 2025 as part of Walmart’s Freshness Guaranteed bakery lineup. The launch features four soda flavored treats: Dr Pepper, Hawaiian Punch, Orange Crush, and 7 Up. These are available as mini cake bites, bundt cakes, and cupcakes. It also includes PB&J inspired items such as PB&J bars, grape jelly cupcakes, and PB&J bites. Finally, the lineup offers s’mores flavored goodies including mini donuts, muffins, frosted cookies, and cupcakes. See sources here and here). Found July 2025.
Milk Chocolate S’mores Popcorn
Score: 6.75 / 10
Review
These are your typical sweet, crunchy, caramelized popcorn you often find in tins. They’re very sugary caramel sweet—and while I think these may have a mild chocolate from the drizzle, it’s hard to perceive because the sweet caramel overpowers it.
Lastly, I’m not sure why these are even labeled as s’mores. Where’s the graham cracker? Marshmallow? And even the chocolate? I may as well have just bought regular caramelized popcorn.
Release Date
Released in early July 2025 as part of Walmart’s Freshness Guaranteed bakery lineup. The launch features four soda flavored treats: Dr Pepper, Hawaiian Punch, Orange Crush, and 7 Up. These are available as mini cake bites, bundt cakes, and cupcakes. It also includes PB&J inspired items such as PB&J bars, grape jelly cupcakes, and PB&J bites. Finally, the lineup offers s’mores flavored goodies including mini donuts, muffins, frosted cookies, and cupcakes. See sources here and here). Found July 2025.
Note: This was made by MJC Confections.
King Krumb Decadent Chocolate Chunk and Confetti Birthday Cake Cookies
Scores:
Decadent Chocolate Chunk: 7 / 10
Confetti Birthday Cake: 7.5 / 10
Review
There is no competition: its competitor, Crumbl, is better. Those cookies are so much fresher, softer, and less artificial-tasting. Not to mention, these absolutely don’t have that “underbaked center” that Crumbl is famous for. Anyway, let’s get on with it…
Decadent Chocolate Chunk: Tastes more or less like a regular store-bought softish cookie with a lightly crunchy outside—you know, the ones you see in the clear generic plastic containers labeled “chocolate chip cookie.” It has your typical artificial (but not bad) mildly sweet chocolate chip flavor and texture. Really, it’s just a regular, plain old store-bought cookie you find from most companies but bigger, both in terms of size and price. Good, but boring.
Confetti Birthday Cake: Close to identical texture to the chocolate: lightly crunchy outside with a softish inside. I think what drives it further than the Decadent Chocolate Chunk are the white chocolate pieces; they do seem to add more weight to these—not physically—they’re simply more noticeable, adding some nuance and creaminess to the texture. Still, it does all feel artificial, though it doesn’t turn out all too bad.
Where it excels is the taste: bringing an especially sweet flavor of vanilla birthday cake. Seriously, I love sweets and put frosting on anything, but these definitely don’t need any more sugar! I also really appreciate how this isn’t just vanilla, as it nails the traditionally sweet birthday cake flavor perfectly. I’d definitely rate this higher if I could have a “fresh” version of these instead of something that felt like it was made to sit around for weeks… perhaps a birthday cake flavored Crumbl cookie!
Release Date
Both released late June 2025 alongside a Triple Chocolate Fudge flavor as well. Found July 2025.
CT Bakery Mini S’mores Filled Donuts
Score: 7.25 / 10
Review
These are large, thick, moist donuts, especially compared to your run-of-the-mill store-bought ones. They’re definitely more on the premium side for sure!
However, since it’s so thick, the dough takes up most of the flavor, which is more or less your typical donut: buttery, mildly sweet dough. The chocolate layer on top just adds a mild chocolate flavor, and there is also a tiny glob of white filling on the inside that resembles a lightly sweet vanilla frosting—yes, unfortunately, not marshmallow as advertised. Lastly, the graham cracker dusting does nothing in terms of flavor or texture.
These are good doughy-tasting donuts. I’d like to see them have more inside marshmallow and chocolate to really bring it up to a s’mores level and counteract all the dough, however.
Release Date
Released in early July 2025 as part of Walmart’s Freshness Guaranteed bakery lineup. The launch features four soda flavored treats: Dr Pepper, Hawaiian Punch, Orange Crush, and 7 Up. These are available as mini cake bites, bundt cakes, and cupcakes. It also includes PB&J inspired items such as PB&J bars, grape jelly cupcakes, and PB&J bites. Finally, the lineup offers s’mores flavored goodies including mini donuts, muffins, frosted cookies, and cupcakes. See sources here and here). Found July 2025.
Sprinkles Cupcake Cups Birthday Cake and Red Velvet
Scores: 7.25 (for both)
Review
These little bags come with Reese’s shaped cups that are individually wrapped.
Birthday Cake: Soft, creamy, and easy to bite through. There are also little crunchy sprinkles on top, which add to the composition of the texture. Flavor-wise, it’s vanilla, not necessarily birthday cake. That’s really it: decently sweet vanilla cups.
Red Velvet: Biting in, I notice there’s not nearly as much creme as shown on the package. Instead, the shell is a little thicker, and the white creme inside is smaller, kind of like a Reese’s (to note, it is not nearly as sweet!). The flavor of the shell is a light red velvet-like chocolate, but it doesn’t exactly nail it. Similarly, the inside creme tries to be cream cheese; however, it instead resembles a moderately sweet creme with vanilla tones.
When frozen, unlike their Reese’s counterpart, they get hard and crunchy, so I’d avoid doing this!
Release Date
Released May 12, 2024.. There is also a Double Chocolate flavor. Found it at Walmart in April 2025.
Sprinkles Red Velvet Chocolate Bar
Score: 7.5 / 10
Review
I’ve never had a red velvet chocolate bar before! This has a very pleasant, moderately sweet red velvet flavor. Honestly, the sweetness is perfect and is unoffending. The inner filling is extremely thin and doesn’t add much in terms of flavor or texture. All of the flavor comes from the red velvet chocolate shell.
Release Date
Released March 2024 along with other varieties by the Sprinkles Cupcake Bakery. Found at Walmart July 2024.