Reviewing Peeps Breyers, Goldfish Cinnamon Roll Grahams, & More

These have a soft, fulfilling crunch, much different than traditional crunchy Goldfish. They’re soft enough to melt in your mouth like a soft, thick biscuit. These also come with a moderately sweet, cinnamon-sugar taste. This pairs nicely with the graham cracker taste of the fish itself. Nothing comes across as artificial or bad; in fact, it kind of reminds me of Cinnamon Toast Crunch!

Released in late December 2024, along with Vanilla Cupcake and Strawberry Shortcake flavors. Found at Stop & Shop.

Coming in a smidge less sweet than regular Peeps, these instead have a creamy vanilla taste. The cookie part, however, isn’t at all noticeable; instead, there are just little dark specks that seem to be just for decoration.

Released January 2025. Found at Walmart.

Vanilla is the only thing I can think of. The soft-hard, almost stiff cookie part has your classic Golden Oreo taste, and the creme in the middle is exactly like an Oreo. Essentially, it’s a puffed-up Golden Oreo. My criticism is that I wish the cookie part was a little less stiff and, instead, more moist and chewy. Other than that, the flavor and texture are good enough.

Rereleased after a decade of being absent in early January 2025. Found at Walmart.