Reviewing Chilli’s Reese’s Cake, Subway Oreo Cookie, Peeps Tropical Punch, & More

What differentiates these from regular Big Cups is the fairly thick, crunchy bits embedded throughout the entire Reese’s peanut filling. Really, the image shows them the actual size! They provide a noticeable crunch, adding positively to the soft-solid, creamy peanut butter. Other than that, these are regular Big Cup Reese’s… but better (in my opinion)!

Released in late January 2025 for the Easter and spring seasons. Found at Walmart.

Thick and crunchy, and the taste is definitely reminiscent of ribs slathered in typical BBQ sauce. These chips are meaty and smoky and have a tasty BBQ flavor that is much different from other meaty and BBQ chips. If you’re into ribs, you’ll very much enjoy these!

Not sure when this was released. Found at Dollar Tree.

It’s mostly a regular marshmallow but slightly more stiff. The lettering on top is crunchy, which adds texture. Taste-wise, it tastes like a normal marshmallow with the slightest hint of bitterness from the dye, offsetting how pleasant it is to eat.

Surprisingly refreshing! It genuinely tastes like a tropical fruit punch, but it is nothing too artificial or fake, either. I can’t point to exactly what kind of fruit it is; it’s like a mix of them. Flavor aside, the texture is identical to that of other peeps.

It was likely first released in January 2035, but it may have been a rebrand of a previous flavor. Found at Dollar Tree.

Texture-wise, despite not a lot of inner filling, they are very soft, easy to bite through, and feel premium. They’re soft biscuits that don’t come across as dry.

Lemon: The lemon is refreshingly sweet without being all that punchy, and combined with the equally light creamy white chocolate, it’s a great combination. The buttery soft wafers also provide a great addition to the flavor.

Coconut: I can’t get over the fact these taste like artificial coconut flavoring. It’s on the stronger side and feels artificial. It’s sort of creamy from the inner filling, but unfortunately, the coconut is just a bit too much.

Strawberry: On the initial bite, I get a good bit of pleasant strawberry flavor that isn’t too artificial, then chewing through, it goes away quickly, leaving a creamy white chocolate strawberry. Like the Lemon flavor, these are quite refreshing!

Released in late January 2025.

Birthday Cake: They’re crunchy and on the drier side. The taste is clearly vanilla birthday cake and reminds me of a crunchy, buttery sugar cookie. Definitely enjoyable, especially if you like vanilla or birthday cake flavors.

S’mores: the cookie itself is a blend of chocolate marshmallow and graham/cookie flavor. I especially like how the chocolate flavor is stronger than the other two because, in real smores, chocolate usually overpowers the others. Note: It has a milk chocolate flavor. Other than that, the few bits in the crunchy cookie are soft, although there aren’t too many to make that much of a difference:

Churro: Churro? Eh, not really. It’s a lightly dusted, crunchy cinnamon sugar cookie. It’s not very sweet nor cinnamony enough to really be super enjoyable. It’s just okay and tolerable.

These were likely released around September 2024. Found at Price Rite.

Sweet, much sweeter than regular cannoli filling, and almost as sweet as the Aldi Snickerdoodle Can cannoli flavor. In terms of flavor, it’s definitely a pretty accurate creamy salted caramel. It’s great with crackers and biscuits, and I could see this being the filling of a cannoli, although you may need to use a lot less than what’s typically used because of how sweet it is!

Released in December 2023 for a limited time, along with other flavors (another review from October 2024, here). These have come back in 2024 as well.

This cake really reminds me of a thick peanut butter cheesecake. It’s incredibly creamy and dense and has a pleasant Reese’s peanut butter taste. The good amount of embedded chips adds a nice crunchy texture. The bottom consists of a thick ganache and a sweet cookie-like dark chocolate crust, much like a Reese’s cup in terms of taste! Overall, it’s a great cake, but nothing too special or write home about. It could really use vanilla ice cream or whipped cream.

Released November 2024.

A decently sweet, soft, and moist dark chocolate cookie. The taste almost resembles an Oreo cookie, except the white stuff in the middle is completely bland. This filling is thick, and the texture resembles a thicker, stretchy marshmallow fluff. If they could just improve the white filling by making it sweeter and creamier, this would be so much better!

Released late January 2025.

These are really close in flavor to their typical frosted donuts. The difference is that these also have a faint creamy, vanilla, strawberry taste. Other than that, they feel a bit cheap, with a semi-dry texture and cheap-feeling frosted coating. I wish these were sweeter, too!

Not sure when this was released, although it’s likely a Valentine’s season exclusive. Found at Walmart.